Spunzo

The Un-Spun Zone.

Composite story

Two charged after a man in a cardboard box was run over at Bethany Cemetery

Police say a driver ran over Carl Michael Kinley, who was under a cardboard box at a Valley Station cemetery, then left. A groundskeeper is charged with trying to cover it up.

Louisville Metro Police say Carl Michael Kinley, 45, was run over on Sept. 15 while under a cardboard box at Bethany Cemetery on Dixie Highway in Valley Station. Brad Brinkley was charged with reckless homicide and leaving the scene. Groundskeeper Thomas Litsey was charged with complicity to tampering with physical evidence.

Shared facts

Louisville Metro Police arrested Brad Brinkley and Thomas Litsey.

Police said the death was a hit-and-run at a Louisville cemetery.

The death happened at Bethany Cemetery.

Carl Michael Kinley was fatally run over.

Brad Brinkley is 40.

Thomas Litsey is 60.

Charles Barbe identified his brother as Carl "Mikey" Michael Kinley.

Carl Michael Kinley was 45.

Kinley was inside a large cardboard box.

Police described the box as large enough to fit a refrigerator.

Police placed the collision on a Tuesday.

Brad Brinkley is accused of driving over Kinley with a truck.

Tire marks indicated the cardboard box had been run over.

The box had tire marks on it.

After the impact, Brinkley drove back to see what he had hit.

Brinkley saw Kinley's hand sticking out of the crushed box.

Witnesses said Brinkley sat in his truck with his head down, then left without speaking to anyone.

Cemetery staff said Brinkley usually stayed after funerals and helped remove tarps.

Cemetery employees flagged down a Louisville Metro police officer.

LMPD officers responded to a report of a person down at the cemetery.

A man was found dead at the cemetery.

Brinkley told groundskeeper Litsey what happened.

Police said Brinkley told Litsey he knew he had run over a person before leaving.

Police say Thomas Litsey tried to cover up Brinkley's role.

Litsey first said he found the body, then said Brinkley told him about it.

Thomas Litsey was a groundskeeper at the cemetery.

Thomas Litsey was charged with complicity to tampering with physical evidence.

Brad Brinkley was charged with reckless homicide.

Brinkley was also charged with leaving the scene, tampering with physical evidence, and failing to report the crash.

LMPD moved the case from the Homicide Unit to the Traffic Unit.

LMPD said Kinley walked into the cemetery on his own.

Police believe Kinley was alive under the box before he was run over.

Kinley died of blunt force trauma.

A judge set Brinkley's bond at $250,000 and Litsey's bond at $50,000.

Brinkley and Litsey are due back in court later this month.

Police said Brinkley could not explain why he left without calling them after seeing the hand.

Charles Barbe said he had a million questions.

The family questioned why Kinley was in the box.

Charles Barbe said he had never heard of his brother sleeping in a cardboard box.

Charles Barbe said his brother struggled with drugs.

Barbe said Kinley lived nearby and rented a room.

Shared opinions

Charles Barbe said everybody loved Kinley.

Charles Barbe described Kinley as someone who would give up food or clothing to help someone.

Charles Barbe said Kinley was just that kind of guy.

Louisville Courier Journal

2 charged after hit-and-run in Louisville cemetery leaves 1 dead

Caroline Neal

Published 18 Sep 2026 accessed 21 Sep 2026

Facts

Brinkley and Litsey were being held at Louisville Metro Department of Corrections.

The cemetery is in the 10000 block of Dixie Highway.

LMPD's Homicide Unit responded and opened a preliminary investigation.

Brinkley and Litsey were scheduled to be arraigned Sept. 18.

The investigation was ongoing.

Opinion

No opinion marked.

WDRB

Family identifies man who died after being run over at Louisville cemetery

Alena Noakes

Published 18 Sep 2026 accessed 21 Sep 2026

Facts

Charles Barbe learned of his brother's death the day after police found him at Bethany Cemetery.

Court documents say Brinkley told police he ran over the cardboard box, felt a bump, and did not check what he hit.

Charles Barbe asked why Kinley was not on camera getting into the box if he was on camera walking in.

LMPD said Kinley did not suffer a gunshot or stab wound.

LMPD said it stands by the arrests and charges.

WDRB called and emailed Bethany Cemetery about the incident and Litsey's job and had not heard back by publication.

Opinion

WDRB said the account was not enough of an explanation for the dead man's loved ones.

Charles Barbe said he might not have a quarrel if the driver had rendered aid and come forward.

Charles Barbe called the driver a dirty dude for running over a cardboard box.

Kinley's family feels many questions have gone unanswered.

New York Post

Man sleeping in cardboard box at Louisville cemetery crushed to death in hit-and-run

Daniel Cody

Published 19 Sep 2026 accessed 21 Sep 2026

Facts

No unique facts.

Opinion

The Post says Brinkley allegedly did not realize Carl Michael Kinley was sleeping inside the box.

The Mirror US

Man in cardboard box at cemetery crushed to death in alleged hit-and-run

Yelena Mandenberg

Published 20 Sep 2026 accessed 21 Sep 2026

Facts

Police said Kinley was run over on September 15.

The cemetery is in the Valley Station area of Louisville.

Brinkley is accused of then leaving the property.

Brinkley is from Hanover, Indiana.

Opinion

The Mirror said that habit made his sudden departure stand out.